nun hab ich doch nochmal eine Frage bzw. zwei unterschiedliche Auslegungen gefunden.
Es geht um das Wintering von Wallace und Moray
Laut Regel 5.8 ELIMINATED BLOCKS
When blocks are eliminated, they
are placed in a player's Draw Pool and
may return to the game during an English
Feudal Levy or Scots Winter Build.
EXCEPTION: When eliminated in Battle,
blocks with a black cross (see sidebar, z.B. Wallace, Moray)
are permanently eliminated. All blocks
eliminated as a consequence of the Pillage
Card, Border Raids, or Winter Attrition are
disbanded to the Draw Pool.
d.h. für mich Wallace und Moray würden im Draw Pool landen, wenn sie keinen Platz zum Überwintern haben.
in den FAQs steht aber folgendes:
Q. Moray is in Mar with Mar. There is an English infantry in Moray. It is the end of the year. Due to the castle limit, I should choose to put back Moray in Moray, but there is some unwanted guest and Moray cannot switch allegiance. On the other hand, Mar has a castle limit of 1 but the rules states that when wintering I cannot eliminate a noble. So what happens here?
A. The Moray block does not have to return to Moray at the end of the year. Accordingly, it cannot be eliminated simply because the English are sitting in Moray. The block can only be killed in battle or because there’s nowhere for the block to winter. In this example, Mar stays because he’s a conventional noble. Moray dies in this example because he can’t go home (being that it’s occupied by the English) and can’t stay.
(7.2) Wintering with William Wallace
Q. Same kind of situation with Wallace: if Wallace is in an area over the castle limit along with a friendly noble and Selkirk is held by English troops, Wallace is eliminated and therefore removed from the game? If he cannot winter the man leaves the rebellion for good?
A. Yes.
allerdings werden vor den FAQs auch noch kurz die Änderungen der Regel von 1.0 auf 1.2 aufgeführt. Aktuelle Regelversion ist allerdings 2.3
d.h. die FAQs könnten veraltet sein.
Von daher würde es mich interessieren wie ihr das handhabt.